One way of tackling Paper 2 is to compare and contrast the Classical period with the Middle Ages and the Modern (Nietzsche and Camus) focusing on a different question than your did in the first paper. If you take this route, be sure your focus is on Augustine, Dante, and Nietzsche/Camus and how they differ from what came before them on the last paper. This is only a suggestion. If you have another approach, this is fine. It will show up in your thesis.